Lies on lies on lies in lies
You fooled me once, then twice, three times
Oh, it's my fault, too forgiving
You're the sinner, but I'm sinning
'Cause I love you still
And I'm scared 'cause I think I always will

Shame on, shame on, shame on you
For making me think that we're through
You're too tempting, I can't help it
Wanna tell you that I'm selfish
'Cause I love you still
And I'm scared 'cause I think I always will

Please, oh, please, let my heart free
I think this time it's come to me
That I'll be careful, I'll push through it
But my soul says I can't do it
'Cause I love you still
And I'm scared 'cause I know I always will