C
Same day, same night
       G
Always feeling it our fights
       Am                      F
Like a fire in an empty house
C
Gone off somewhere
    G
All I know is you’re not here
    Am                        F
You think I’d have learned by now


[Pre Chorus]
C
You say she’s just a friend, well okay
          G
Why’s she showing up at

Midnight on my birthday?
          Am
Why’s she crying in your arms

Looking like a mess?
     F
And you’re looking at me

Like you gotta confess?
C
Not the first time you held her
   G
Mascara stains dripping down your t-shirt
        Am
Now I’m packing my bag, but I gotta ask
       F
Out of everyone, everyone else


[Chorus]
                    C
Why’d it have to be Hailey?
                    G
Why’d it have to be Hailey?
       Am
Out of everyone, everyone else
       F
Out of everyone, everyone else
                    C
Why’d it have to be Hailey?
                    G
Why’d it have to be Hailey?
        Am
Out of everyone, everyone else
        F
Out of everyone, everyone else


[Verse 2]
C                         G
You say that I’ve got it all wrong
              Am                    F
But I think I know you better than myself
C                      G                  Am
Don’t you get tired of always playing the victim
             F
And running your mouth?


[Pre-Chorus]
C
You say she’s just a friend, well okay
          G
Why’s she showing up at

Midnight on my birthday?
          Am
Why’s she crying in your arms

Looking like a mess?
     F
And you’re looking at me

Like you gotta confess?
C
Not the first time you held her
   G
Mascara stains dripping down your t-shirt
        Am
Now I’m packing my bag, but I gotta ask
       F
Out of everyone, everyone else


[Chorus]
                    C
Why’d it have to be Hailey?
                    G
Why’d it have to be Hailey?
       Am
Out of everyone, everyone else
       F
Out of everyone, everyone else
                    C
Why’d it have to be Hailey?
                    G
Why’d it have to be Hailey?
        Am
Out of everyone, everyone else
        F
Out of everyone, everyone else.


[Bridge]
C*
   “Are you gonna tell her?”
                        G*
    “There’s no point.”
                          Am*
    “She’s gonna find out eventually.”
            F*
    “I mean it doesn’t matter
                         F strumming increases
     If she does at this point.”


[Chorus]
                    C
Why’d it have to be Hailey?
                    G
Why’d it have to be Hailey?
       Am
Out of everyone, everyone else
       F
Out of everyone, everyone else
                    C
Why’d it have to be Hailey?
                    G
Why’d it have to be Hailey?
        Am
Out of everyone, everyone else
        F
Out of everyone, everyone else


[Outro]
                    C*
Why’d it have to be Hailey?
                    G*
Why’d it have to be Hailey?
       Am*
Out of everyone, everyone else
       F*
Out of everyone, everyone else