G                    Em                    Bm
I can't say goodbye, I can't say goodnight
Bm                                         G
I can't say goodbye, I can't say goodnight
G                  Em                  Bm
Can't say goodbye, can't say goodnight
                                         G  A
Can't say goodnight, can't say goodnight

[Chorus]
  Bm                        Em
I wanna go back to when the screams were real
    D                    A
And beautiful terror is what I wanna feel
Bm            Em                  D        A
Dripping over me like a long lost memory
Bm                          Em
I wanna go back to when the nights were red
D                    A
Mechanized agony and trouble in my head
G                     Em
It wasn't good, and I don't feel bad
D                          Gb
Those five nights were the best I've ever had

[Instrumental]
G Bm Bm
F# G#m D

[Verse 1]
Bm                       F#
Where did you go, all my friendly nightmares?
G                       F#
My skin is crawling and nobody cares
Bm                      G#m
Shadows are falling and I will catch them
G            F#
In my dreams tonight

Bm                      G#m
I can smell the oil and I can taste the past
  G                        F#          F
I shiver and recoil at the demons I've amassed
Bm                      D
They keep me company so I will never be alone
G                              F#
I'm trapped in my mind, but my mind is not my own

[Pre-Chorus]
G            Bm
Why does the pain remain inside?
                            A  G
I will never, never be sure
          Em            Bm
But if it disappeared I wouldn't know
Who I was anymore

[Instrumental]
G F#

[Chorus]
  Bm                        Em
I wanna go back to when the screams were real
    D                    A
And beautiful terror is what I wanna feel
Bm            Em                  D        A
Dripping over me like a long lost memory
Bm                          Em
I wanna go back to when the nights were red
D                    A
Mechanized agony and trouble in my head
G                     Em
It wasn't good, and I don't feel bad
D                          Gb
Those five nights were the best I've ever had

[Instrumental]
G F#
G Bm
G F#

[Verse 2]
    Bm
Oh, now the night is over and I can feel the sun
G                            F#
It's been forever since I've had a little fun
Bm                           D          G
My blood is pumping but I've never felt less alive
                           F#
I wish that I could go back to night number five

Bm                       G#m
It may be crazy but I've always been a little strange
G                         F#
And if you wanna join me, that can be arranged
Bm                         G#m                D
So let's go back and let's relive the time we thought we'd die
G                           F#               D
And if we make it out we'll have ourselves a pizza pie

[Pre-Chorus]
G                E               Bm
Why does the pain remain inside?
                       A     G
I will never, never be sure
          Em            Bm
But if it disappeared I wouldn't know

Who I was anymore

[Instrumental]
G F#

[Chorus]
  Bm                         G
I wanna go back to when the screams were real
    D                   A
And beautiful terror is what I wanna feel
Bm            G              D        A
Dripping over me like a long lost memory
  Bm                        Em
I wanna go back to when the nights were red
D                    A
Mechanized agony and trouble in my head
   G                  Em
It wasn't good, and I don't feel bad
D                          F#
Those five nights were the best I've ever had

[Outro]
Bm D Bm
Bm D Em