Lost in her cerulean eyes I wore masks, lived in disguise Pretending to be what I'm not But she saw through, my tangled plot Blue-eyed girl, lost in the past Our love couldn't forever last Played a game I couldn't win Haunted now, by what might've been Searching in crowds, she's not there Her laughter haunts, in the air She's gone, vanished without a trace Leaving me alone in this empty space If I could turn back time, make it right But she's gone, out of sight Love lost in my web of lies Forever haunted by her blue eyes Blue-eyed girl, lost in the past Our love couldn't forever last Played a game I couldn't win Haunted now, by what might've been In the silence of the night, I call her name But she's gone, swallowed by the flame A love lost in the depths of my lies Forever haunted by her blue eyes