Do I? Do I love him? Do I? Midnight stands about a head above Anyone I've ever know Velvet eyes that hypnotise and burn me Midnight's just an old romantic fool With nineteenth - century lines Sending tingling, thrilling chills That turn me on Do I? Do I love him? Do I? Don't say Goodnight, Midnight You may turn into a pumpkin, don't go We only just said hello! Oh, my dear! Don't say Goodnight, Midnight Do I? Do I love him? Do I? Midnight has a confidential mind His heart is in a safe I'm still trying to find the combination Got to keep my midnight free When Midnight comes to call Just to be my sole and sweet temptation, ooh! Do I? Do I love him? Do I? Don't say Goodnight, Midnight You may turn into a pumpkin, don't go We only just said hello! Oh, my dear! Don't say Goodnight, Midnight You may turn into a pumpkin, don't go We only just said hello! Oh, my dear! Don't say Goodnight, Midnight